Good Housekeeping reveal winners of its BBQ food blind taste test

Tesco has been crowned king of the bangers after its £5.50 chorizo sausages came out on top in The Good Housekeeping Institute’s 2021 BBQ food blind taste test.

The retailer was also crowned joint winner with Waitrose of the best supermarket beef burger category. 

Eversfield Organic Beef Steak Burgers came in first overall when it came to meat patties, while the Waitrose & Partners Vegetarian Aubergine and Feta Burgers, priced at £2.75, achieved the highest overall score for burgers. 

Of the BBQ accompaniments, Lidl was victorious in the best cheese category with its own brand 65p mature cheddar slices, while the Mondo Brewing Co’s Little Victories and Brick Brewery’s Peckham Session won best IPAs. 

With an impressive score of 87/100, Eversfield Organic’s Beef Steak Burgers, which cost £6.76 for a pack of four, have nabbed the top spot this year for best beef burger

Pictured, smoky Tesco Fire Pit Chorizo Sausages, £4 for a pack of six

Pictured, Lidl's own brand Mature Cheddar Slices, 65p for 200g

Tesco was crowned winner of the best sausages category with their £4 smoky Tesco Fire Pit Chorizo Sausages (left) while Lidl was victorious in the best cheese category with its own brand 65p mature cheddar slices 

With an impressive score of 87/100, the Eversfield Organic Beef Steak Burgers, which cost £6.76 for a pack of four, were described as rich and succulent.

Runner-up with a score of 83/100 went to Swaledale Steak Burgers, priced at £9 for a pack of four, which had a distinctive savoury smell that reminded some panellists of salty charcuterie with hints of olives.  

When it came to the battle of the own-brand supermarket beef burger, both Tesco and Waitrose & Partners emerged victorious scoring a matching 78/100. 

Tesco won for its Finest Chuck & Brisket Burger, which cost £3 for two burgers, while the Waitrose & Partners No 1 Dry Aged Hereford Steak Burgers, priced at £4.25 for a packet of two, equally impressed the judges.

Swaledale North African Spiced Lamb Kofta Kebabs, £8, were a joint winner when it came to the best meat and fish kebabs

Swaledale North African Spiced Lamb Kofta Kebabs, £8, were a joint winner when it came to the best meat and fish kebabs 

Pictured, Waitrose Vegetarian Aubergine and Feta Burgers at £2.75

Pictured, Moving Mountains Sausage, £4.69 for 228g

The crown for the best vegetarian burger was awarded to to Waitrose for its Vegetarian Aubergine and Feta Burgers (£2.75) while the best vegan sausages went to Moving Mountains Sausage, £4.69

Tesco proved to be the number one destination when it came to sausages, winning best overall sausage for its hearty, smoky Tesco Fire Pit Chorizo Sausages, £4 for a pack of six.

Aldi took the crown for best budget sausages with a score of 81/100 for its Specially Selected Monterey Jack and Jalapeno Hot Dogs (£1.99). 

In the battle of the skewers, Swaledale North African Spiced Lamb Kofta Kebabs, £8, were a joint winner alongside Aldi’s Salmon Kebabs, £2.99.  

And the crown for the best vegetarian burger was awarded to Waitrose for its Vegetarian Aubergine and Feta Burgers, priced at £2.75 for two.

Aldi's Salmon Kebabs, priced at £2.99, were a joint winner when it came to meat and fish kebabs

Aldi’s Salmon Kebabs, priced at £2.99, were a joint winner when it came to meat and fish kebabs 

Pictured, Mondo Brewing Co. Little Victories Session IPA , £2.79 for 330ml (4.3% ABV)

Pictured, Brick Brewery Peckham Session, £2.79 for 330ml (4.2% ABV)

Mondo Brewing Co. (left) tied with Brick Brewery (right) for best IPA, with their offerings costing £2.79 per 330ml and £2.79 per 330ml, respectively 

The best vegan burger and sausages were awarded to Moving Mountains, with its burger achieving a score of 81/100 and sausages racking up a score of 89/100.  

The leader of the pack when it came to supermarket vegan sausages was M&S, scoring a solid 85/100 for its Plant Kitchen Chorizo Puppies, which cost £3.50 for a pack of four.  

Runner-up to Lidl in the cheese category, with a score of 79/100, was Sainsbury’s, with its Taste the Difference Barbers Cruncher Cheddar Slices £2 for 150g.  

The best vegan burger was awarded to Moving Mountains, with its burger achieving a score of 81/100 at a price of £4.92 for 227g (2 pack)

The best vegan burger was awarded to Moving Mountains, with its burger achieving a score of 81/100 at a price of £4.92 for 227g (2 pack)

Violife Non-Dairy Cheese Alternative Slices, 200g, £2.99

Linda McCartney Vegetarian Lincolnshire Sausages, 300g (6pk), £2.20

The best vegan cheese slices were Violife Non-Dairy Cheese Alternative Slices at £2.99 while Linda McCartney Vegetarian Lincolnshire Sausages at £2.20 were runner-up for best vegan sausages 

Mondo Brewing Co. tied with Brick Brewery for best IPA, with their offerings costing £2.79 per 330ml and £2.79 per 330ml, respectively.  

Stacey Smith, Food and Drink Editor at the Good Housekeeping Institute, said: ‘This summer might be the first opportunity for many of us to spend quality time with much-missed family and friends. 

‘With that in mind, The Good Housekeeping Institute has been busy conducting its comprehensive BBQ taste test, to ensure every gathering is as tasty as can be. 

‘Catering for every budget and diet, it’s great to see value supermarkets compete with online butchers, alongside a swell of innovative meat-free products.’

Good Housekeeping 2021 BBQ taste test: The full winners 

Beef burgers 

Winner: Eversfield Organic Beef Steak Burgers, 460g (4pk), £6.76 

Score: 87/100

Runner up: Swaledale Steak Burgers, 600g (4pk), £9 

Score: 83/100

Best budget four-pack 

Winner: field&flower (4pk), £5.48 

Score: 80/100 

Best supermarket beef burgers 

Winner: Tesco Finest Chuck & Brisket Burger, 227g (2pk), £3 

Score: 78/100

Winner: Waitrose & Partners No 1 Dry Aged Hereford Steak Burgers, 340g (2pk), £4.25

Score: 78/100

Vegetarian burger 

Winner: Waitrose & Partners Vegetarian Aubergine and Feta Burgers, £2.75 for 210g (2 pack)

Score: 88/100

Best budget vegetarian burger 

Winner: Linda McCartney Mozzarella Burgers, 227g, (2pk), £2.20

Score: 71/100

Vegan burger

Winner: Moving Mountains Burger, £4.92 for 227g (2 pack) 

Score: 81/100 

Best budget vegan burger 

Winner: ASDA Plant Based Meat Free Triple Chilli Burgers, 227g, (2pk), £2.35

Score: 80/100

Best chicken centrepiece 

Winner: Waitrose & Partners Chicken Shawarma King Kebab, 900g (1pk), £8, due in store and online late April

Score: 88/100

Best cheese slices 

Winner: Lidl’s own brand Mature Cheddar Slices, 65p for 200g 

Score: 83/100

Runner up: Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Barbers Cruncher Cheddar Slices £2 for 150g

Score: 79/100 

Best vegan cheese slice 

Winner: Violife Non-Dairy Cheese Alternative Slices, 200g, £2.99

Score: 72/100  

Best sausages 

Winner: Tesco Fire Pit Chorizo Sausages, 300g (6pk), £4

Score: 88/100

Runner up: Piper’s Farm Natural Cumberland Sausages,500g (6pk), £5.50

Score: 85/100

Best budget sausages

Winner: Aldi Specially Selected Monterey Jack and Jalapeno Hot Dogs, 400g (4 pk), £1.99, in store only

Score: 81/100

Best meat and seafood kebabs

Winner: Swaledale North African Spiced Lamb Kofta Kebab, £8 for 400g (4 pack)

Score: 90/100 

Winner: Aldi’s Salmon Kebabs, £2.99 for 206g (4 pack) 

Score: 90/100  

Runner up: M&S British Fully Loaded Lamb Shish Kebabs with a Creamy Citrus Yoghurt Dressing, £8.50 for 500g (2 pack) 

Score: 90/100 

Best beef kebab 

Winner: field&flower Teriyaki Marinated Beef Skewers, 200g, (2pk), £4.10

Score: 87/100

Vegan sausages 

Winner: Moving Mountains Sausage, £4.69 for 228g (4 pack) 

Score: 81/100 

Runner up:  Linda McCartney Vegetarian Lincolnshire Sausages, 300g (6pk), £2.20

Score: 88/100 

Supermarket vegan sausages 

Winner: M&S Plant Kitchen Chorizo Puppies, £3.50 for 360g (4 pack) 

Score: 85/100

Best Session IPAs

Winner: Mondo Brewing Co. Little Victories Session IPA , £2.79 for 330ml (4.3% ABV)

Score:  83/100

Winner: Brick Brewery Peckham Session, £2.79 for 330ml (4.2% ABV)

Score: 83/100