Fury as Keir Starmer stays SILENT over  ‘vile’ Priti Patel letter from Labour MPs

Fury as Keir Starmer stays SILENT over ‘vile’ letter from Labour MPs accusing Priti Patel of ‘gaslighting’ BLM protests by talking about her own experiences of racism – while Sadiq Khan jibes that she ‘lacks emotional intelligence’

  • Keir Starmer staying silent over letter from Labour MPs rebuking Priti Patel 
  • Accused Home Secretary of ‘gaslighting’ by referring to own racism experience 
  • London mayor Sadiq Khan swiped that Ms Patel ‘lacks emotional intelligence’

Keir Starmer is facing huge pressure to condemn a letter from dozens of his MPs accusing Priti Patel of ‘gaslighting’ Black Lives Matter protesters by talking about her own experiences of racism.

The Labour leader has refused to criticise the letter, signed by frontbenchers, despite a wave of outrage and fury from the Home Secretary.

Meanwhile, London mayor Sadiq Khan defended the MPs for demanding Ms Patel recognise that racism against the black community was ‘different’, swiping that she ‘lacked emotional intelligence’.  

The Labour politicians laid into Ms Patel for the way she spoke about her own background as the daughter of Gujarati refugees from Uganda during a Commons debate on BLM demos earlier this week.

The letter voiced ‘dismay at the way you used your heritage and experiences of racism to gaslight the very real racism faced by Black people and communities across the UK’.

London mayor Sadiq Khan defended the MPs for demanding she recognise that racism against the black community was ‘different’, swiping that she ‘lacked emotional intelligence’

Dozens of Labour MPs have put their name to a letter to Priti Patel expressing 'dismay at the way you used your heritage and experiences of racism to gaslight the very real racism faced by Black people and communities across the UK'

Dozens of Labour MPs have put their name to a letter to Priti Patel expressing ‘dismay at the way you used your heritage and experiences of racism to gaslight the very real racism faced by Black people and communities across the UK’

Neil O'Brienwas among the Tories demanding that Sir Keir speak out on the issue today

Neil O’Brienwas among the Tories demanding that Sir Keir speak out on the issue today

Patel’s searing retort to MPs who claimed she ‘did not understand racial inequality’ 

Priti Patel delivered a searing retort in the Commons on Monday to MPs suggesting she did not ‘understand racial inequality’.

‘On that basis, it must have been a very different Home Secretary who as a child was frequently called a Paki in the playground,’ she said.

‘A very different Home Secretary who was racially abused in the streets or even advised to drop her surname and use her husband’s in order to advance her career. 

‘A different Home Secretary recently characterised, if madam deputy speaker I can say so, in The Guardian newspaper as a fat cow with a ring through its nose – something that was not only racist but offensive, both culturally and religiously.

‘This is hardly an example of respect, equality, tolerance or fairness. So, when it comes to racism, sexism, tolerance for social justice, I will not take lectures from the other side of the House.’ 

In a stinging rebuke, they said: ‘Being a person of colour does not automatically make you an authority on all forms of racism.’

However, an incensed Ms Patel shot back: ‘I will not be silenced by @UKLabour MPs who continue to dismiss the contributions of those who don’t conform to their view of how ethnic minorities should behave.’

Cabinet ministers have lined up behind their colleague, with Matt Hancock swiping that critics seemed to ‘think there is such a thing as the wrong type of BAME’. ‘We think that people are equal,’ he told the daily Downing Street briefing. 

Former chancellor Sajid Javid posted on Twitter: ‘Imagine listening to an ethnic-minority woman’s history of suffering racist abuse – and then deciding that you’d rather condemn the victim than her abusers. 

‘All because she doesn’t fit your stereotype. An utterly misguided and irresponsible letter.’ 

Labour sources stressed that the letter was organised by the MPs themselves rather than the party, and declined to say whether Sir Keir agreed with the content. 

Shadow chancellor Anneliese Dodds today dodged the issue by saying she would not ‘speak for my colleagues’, adding that the Government had done ‘nothing’ to tackle racial inequalities. 

But Tory MP Bob Blackman told MailOnline: ‘If you are silent, you condone it. He should be saying, we should not be doing this. A failure to do so is a failure of leadership.’ 

Fellow Conservative Neil O’Brien tweeted: ‘Day two and still no condemnation of this vile letter from Starmer – thought he was better than that.’ 

A senior Tory source: “Starmer now needs to pick a side on this. He either needs to condone or condemn – and quickly” 

Mr Khan told Sky News he was ‘not sure’ whether Ms Patel’s words amount to ‘gaslighting’, and said he did not doubt she had suffered racism.

But he said the Labour MPs had been pointing out that she should show ‘respect’ and ‘understand that everyone’s experiences are different’. 

‘I think what the MPs were calling for is some empathy and sympathy from Priti Patel,’ he said. ‘She is the Home Secretary with a huge amount of a power.

‘When you lead with words like ”thuggery”, ”recklessness” and ”criminality” it shows a lack of emotional intelligence.’ 

Speaking on BBC Breakfast earlier, Ms Dodds said: ‘I’m not going to speak for my colleagues, and actually as I understand it, part of what they are pointing attention to is the fact that black people’s voices often haven’t been heard and they need to be heard.

‘Now what’s critically important to me and what I find quite frustrating about this is that we know those racial inequalities are there… time and time again people were asking when action was going to come.

‘We’ve had the Windrush review, the Lammy review, and the Public Health England review, all showing there’s substantial racial inequality and prejudice, and nothing being done about it.

‘To me that’s got to be the focus, we’ve got to take action against these inequalities.’

The full letter from Labour MPs to Home Secretary Priti Patel  

RE: Shared feelings allow us to show solidarity not gaslight other minority communities

Dear Rt Hon Priti Patel MP,

We write to you as Black Asian and Ethnic Minority Labour MPs to highlight our dismay at the way you used your heritage and experiences of racism to gaslight the very real racism faced by Black people and communities across the UK.

In the chamber in response to one of our colleagues, you stated,

‘When it comes to racism, sexism, tolerance for social justice, I will not take lectures from the other side of the House.’

We all have our personal stories, of the racism that we have faced, whether it has been being defined by the colour of our skin or the faith we choose to believe in.

Our shared experiences allow us to feel the pain that communities feel, when they face racism, they allow us to show solidarity towards a common cause; they do not allow us to define, silence or impede on the feelings that other minority groups may face.

Being a person of colour does not automatically make you an authority on all forms of racism.

Structures of racism, hatred and inequality have many layers and therefore, whilst it is true, there are some experiences of racism that we all face, there are also some experiences of racism that we all do not face.

Some forms have become acceptable in our communities, others exist under the breaths and many are built on unconscious bias and systemic structures of power.

The murder of George Floyd brought to light, the authentic experiences of Black men, women and children in the US and the UK from Police brutality, through to the structural and institutional racism that unjustly targets black communities in the UK. Those experiences can not be silenced by some shared feeling.

In conclusion, we ask you to reflect on your words and to consider the impact it had towards black communities in the UK trying to highlight their voices against racism.

Rest assured, that Asian and Ethnic Minority colleagues on this side of the house will not use their experiences to silence our Black colleagues, but will use our shared experiences to stand behind them and support their voices to lead us on standing up against the distinct form of racism black communities in the UK and across the globe face.

#BlackLivesMatter

Best wishes, 

 Naz Shah MP

Marsha De Cordova MP 

Diane Abbott MP 

Afzal Khan MP

Mohammed Yasin MP 

Imran Hussain MP 

Shabana Mahmood MP

Tan Dhesi MP 

Virendra Sharma MP 

Sir Mark Hendrick MP

Nadia Whittome MP 

Rushanara Ali MP  

Khalid Mahmood MP

Tulip Siddiq MP 

Zarah Sultana MP 

Preet Kaur Gill MP 

Kate Osamor MP 

Chi Onwurah MP  

Clive Lewis MP

Rupa Huq MP 

Bell Ribeiro Addy MP 

Sarah Owen MP

Rosena Allin-Khan MP 

Florence Eshalomi MP 

Claudia Webb MP

Yasmin Qureshi MP 

Apsana Begum MP 

Feryal Clark MP

Taiwo Owatemi MP 

Seema Malhotra MP 

Dawn Butler MP

Valerie Vaz MP